Management information systems. Integrated Case Narrative Ap…

Integrated Case Narrative

Apex Retail Group (ARG): Managing Information Systems in the Digital Age

Part I: MIS in the Digital Age

Apex Retail Group (ARG) was founded fifteen years ago as a traditional brick-and-mortar retailer specializing in consumer electronics and home appliances. For most of its early years, the company relied heavily on managerial experience, intuition, and periodic financial reports to make decisions. As operations expanded across Bahrain, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE, the volume of data generated by sales transactions, inventory movements, customer interactions, and employee activities increased significantly.

Despite this growth, ARGs management continued to operate with outdated and fragmented information systems. Sales data from physical stores, online platforms, and third-party vendors were stored in separate systems, making it difficult to obtain a single, reliable version of business information. Managers often received reports weeks after events had occurred, limiting their ability to respond quickly to market changes.

In the digital agewhere speed, accuracy, and real-time information are criticalARGs traditional approach to information management has become a serious limitation. Senior executives have begun to question whether their existing MIS can adequately support decision-making at the operational, tactical, and strategic levels. The company now faces increasing pressure to modernize its MIS in order to survive and compete in a rapidly digitizing business environment.

Part II: e-Business Enterprise Becoming a Digital Firm

As customer behavior shifted toward online and mobile shopping, ARG attempted to establish an e-commerce presence. While the online platform initially increased sales volume, it also exposed deeper organizational problems. The online store was not integrated with physical retail outlets or warehouse systems, resulting in frequent customer complaints about unavailable products and delayed deliveries.

Suppliers and logistics partners also operated on separate systems, relying on emails and manual confirmations for purchase orders and shipment updates. Internally, departments such as sales, finance, HR, and operations worked in silos, each using its own applications with little data sharing.

ARGs leadership realized that merely having an online store does not make a company a digital firm. A true e-business enterprise requires seamless integration of customers, suppliers, and internal processes through digital technologies. The Board of Directors approved a strategic initiative to transform ARG into a fully integrated digital enterprise by implementing ERP, CRM, and SCM systems supported by cloud technologies.

However, the transition raised several concerns. Managers questioned how digital integration would affect existing workflows, employee roles, and organizational culture. Others worried about the cost of implementation and the readiness of staff to adapt to new digital systems.

Part III: Strategic Management of Business Performance

Although ARG continued to generate revenue, profitability steadily declined. Senior management struggled to identify the underlying causes because performance data was inconsistent, incomplete, and poorly aligned with strategic objectives. Key questions remained unanswered: Which products were truly profitable? Which stores performed best relative to their costs? How effective were marketing campaigns in driving customer loyalty?

Performance measurement at ARG relied mainly on financial indicators, with little emphasis on customer satisfaction, internal process efficiency, or learning and growth. Without integrated MIS tools such as dashboards or business intelligence systems, managers lacked visibility into real-time performance trends.

The CEO emphasized that future MIS investments must not only automate processes but also support strategic management of business performance. There was a growing expectation that MIS should help translate business strategy into measurable KPIs, enable continuous monitoring, and support evidence-based managerial decision-making. The challenge for ARG was to ensure that its digital transformation delivered tangible strategic value rather than becoming a costly technological upgrade with limited business impact.

Part IV: Information Security, Threats, and Management

As ARG expanded its digital footprint, information security emerged as a critical concern. Several incidents revealed weaknesses in the companys approach to protecting information assets. Unauthorized access to payroll data raised concerns about internal controls, while phishing attacks targeting finance staff highlighted low employee awareness of cyber threats.

Customer trust was also at risk. Complaints related to data privacy and concerns about online transaction security began to surface, threatening ARGs reputation in an increasingly competitive market. Backup procedures were inconsistent across departments, and there was no formal incident response plan in place.

Management acknowledged that information security could no longer be treated as a purely technical issue. It required strong managerial oversight, clear policies, risk assessment, and alignment with organizational objectives. As ARG moved toward becoming a digital firm, ensuring the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of information became a strategic priority rather than an operational afterthought.

Consulting Context

ARG has appointed you as a Management Information Systems Consultant to evaluate the companys current situation and recommend an integrated MIS strategy. Your analysis must demonstrate how modern MIS can support digital operations, enable strategic performance management, and address information security risksensuring that technology investments align with business goals and managerial decision-making.

Your recommendations should reflect established MIS principles and frameworks as discussed by Waman Jawadekar and Richard Tedmon, and must be grounded in the realities presented in this case.

Assessment Tasks & Marks Breakdown (45 Marks)

Component 1: MIS in the Digital Age (10 Marks)

Task:
Analyze how a modern MIS can support ARGs digital transformation. Evaluate the role of MIS in:

Decision-making at operational, tactical, and strategic levels

Integration of business functions

Data-driven management in a digital environment

Expected Coverage:

Characteristics of MIS in the digital age

MIS vs traditional information systems

Role of databases, analytics, dashboards, and real-time reporting

Component 2: e-Business Enterprise The Digital Firm (12 Marks)

Task:
Assess ARGs readiness to become a digital firm and propose an e-business model that integrates:

Customers

Suppliers

Internal business processes

Expected Coverage:

Definition and characteristics of a digital firm

B2C, B2B, and internal e-business processes

Use of ERP, CRM, SCM, cloud platforms, and mobile technologies

Benefits and challenges of e-business transformation

Component 3: Strategic Management of Business Performance (13 Marks)

Task:
Explain how MIS can be used to measure, monitor, and improve business performance at ARG.

Expected Coverage:

Strategic alignment between business goals and MIS

Use of MIS in performance measurement (KPIs, dashboards, Balanced Scorecard)

Role of MIS in competitive advantage

Managerial decision support using BI and analytics

Component 4: Information Security, Threats, and Management (10 Marks)

Task:
Identify key information security threats faced by ARG and propose a comprehensive MIS-based security management framework.

Expected Coverage:

Common security threats (internal & external)

Data privacy, integrity, and availability

Risk management, security policies, access control, backups

Managerial role in information security governance

Marking Rubrics (45 Marks)

Component 1: MIS in the Digital Age (10 Marks)

Criteria	Excellent (810)	Good (67)	Satisfactory (45)	Poor (03)
Understanding of MIS concepts	Clear, accurate, and applied to case	Mostly clear, minor gaps	Basic understanding	Weak or incorrect
Application to ARG case	Strong, relevant, insightful	Relevant but limited depth	Generic application	No application

Component 2: e-Business & Digital Firm (12 Marks)

Criteria	Excellent (1012)	Good (79)	Satisfactory (46)	Poor (03)
Digital firm concepts	Comprehensive and accurate	Clear but incomplete	Basic understanding	Weak
e-Business integration	Well-integrated model	Partial integration	Limited linkage	No clear model
Use of examples/technologies	Highly relevant	Mostly relevant	Few examples	None

Component 3: Strategic Management of Business Performance (13 Marks)

Criteria	Excellent (1113)	Good (810)	Satisfactory (57)	Poor (04)
Strategic alignment	Strong, well-articulated	Clear but limited	Basic linkage	Weak
Performance tools	Advanced and relevant	Appropriate tools	Few tools	None
Analytical depth	Insightful analysis	Logical analysis	Descriptive	Minimal

Component 4: Information Security Management (10 Marks)

Criteria	Excellent (810)	Good (67)	Satisfactory (45)	Poor (03)
Identification of threats	Comprehensive	Mostly complete	Limited	Weak
Security solutions	Practical and strategic	Appropriate	Basic	Unrealistic
Governance perspective	Strong managerial focus	Some focus	Limited	None

Overall Assessment Expectations

Clear linkage between technology, strategy, and management

Application of Jawadekar & Tedmon concepts

Logical structure, clarity, and professional presentation

Use of diagrams/frameworks where appropriate

Summary of Case Parts and Marks Allocation

Case Part	Topic Covered	Focus of Analysis	Marks
Part I	MIS in the Digital Age	Role of modern MIS in decision-making, integration of business functions, and support for management in a digital environment	10
Part II	e-Business Enterprise The Digital Firm	Evaluation of digital readiness, e-business integration of customers, suppliers, and internal processes	12
Part III	Strategic Management of Business Performance	Strategic alignment of MIS with business goals, performance measurement, KPIs, dashboards, and decision support	13
Part IV	Information Security, Threats, and Management	Identification of security threats, risk management, governance, and MIS-based security controls	10
Total			45

WRITE MY PAPER