INTL 501 W3 reply 2

Write a discussion reply post:

Camryn Bales posted Feb 18, 2026 2:15 PM

With the intelligence failure of Pearl Harbor still in mind, it became abundantly clear that it was necessary to develop an organized intelligence enterprise that could keep decision makers advised of emerging challenges to the U.S. (Tromblay 2015). This led to the passing of the National Security Act of 1947, which intended to unify the U.S. Intelligence Community and pull away from drastic isolation of agencies. The National Security Act of 1947 had the greatest impact on the U.S. Intelligence Community (IC) because of the way it modernized the foundation of intelligence through creation of a centralized power and allotment of agency responsibilities as well as the role of the Director of Central Intelligence (DCI).

The intelligence failures in the events of Pearl Harbor in 1941 can be attributed to a substantial disconnect between those collecting and analyzing information and the decision-makers, in this case the U.S. Commanders in Pearl Harbor. The surprise attack could have arguably been blunted if the various commanders and departments had coordinated their actions and shared their intelligence (CIA n.d.). In hopes of preventing any future errs of this sort, several governmental powers worked to create the National Security Act of 1947, which established several new foundations of the US IC.

The Act created a National Security Council, a Secretary of Defense, a statutory Joint Chiefs of Staff and a Central Intelligence Agency. The NSC and CIA were set to replace the National Intelligence Authority and the Central Intelligence Group, for functions including intelligence collection, analyzation, and informed decision-making (CIA n.d.). The establishment of the CIA made it the nations first independent organization, responsible for all aspects of intelligence, from collection to dissemination. Although it would conduct both analysis and covert action, the CIA would have no law enforcement powers and stay separate from armed and civilian intelligence divisions (CIA n.d.). The reason for this was to create a united IC without the worry of having too much centralized power.

Another important aspect of the National Security Act of 1947 was the creation of the Director of Central Intelligence (DCI) position. There were a series of National Security Council Intelligence Directives (NSCIDs) written into the Act outlining the responsibilities of the DCI, specifically the NSCID-1 Duties and Responsibilities (CIA n.d.). The DCI was set to make recommendations for intelligence activities as accurately as possible, given his position to coordinate and overview the IC. However, due to the ambiguity imposed by this directive, there was grey area between coordination and control. This ultimately led to a loose oversight on IC issues, and lack of opportunity for the CIA to become an integrator of US intelligence (CIA n.d.).

Revisions to the NSCID-1 were ultimately made after many concerns were raised about it, some characterizing it as uncoordinated efforts and ambiguity written into law (Tromblay 2015). These changes included pushing the DCI to exert more control in common IC issues and programs (1958 version) and maintain his four major responsibilities; (1) plan and review all intelligence activities and spending, submitting annually to the White House the communitys overall program/budget; (2) to produce national intelligence for the President and policymakers; (3) to chair all community-wide advisory panels; (4) and to establish intelligence requirements and priorities (1972 version) (CIA n.d.). After these revisions, the National Security Act of 1947 was able to enforce a more productive and efficient US IC with properly allocated responsibilities and coordination.

All aspects considered, the National Security Act of 1947 was the most impactful event to occur in the history of the IC. It reflected the recognition that peacetime intelligence support to national leaders was increasingly vital, and found a way to unify the agencies of the IC (Tidd 2008). Despite having some minor drawbacks, the Act as a whole created the foundation for what we know as the US IC today, collecting, analyzing, and aiding in decision-making to protect our national security.

References:

Central Intelligence Agency. n.d. “The Creation of the Intelligence Community: Founding Documents.” Washington, DC: Government Printing Office.

Tidd, John M. 2008. “From Revolution to Reform: A Brief History of U.S. Intelligence.” The SAIS Review of International Affairs (28) 1: 5-24.

Tromblay, Darren E. 2015. “The U. S. Domestic Intelligence Enterprise: History, Development, and Operations.” Taylor & Francis Group.