IB Higher-Level Essay

Make my essay 10x better for my Higher Level Essay

In Hamilton, how does Lin-Manuel Mirandas portrayal of Eliza as a foil to Hamiltons endless ambition reveal the emotional cost of legacy building while conveying a message about the art of remembrance?

Hamilton by Lin-Manuel Miranda follows the story of American Founding Father Alexander Hamilton, constructed into a musical. In it, it storytells Hamiltions rise to politics and influence, but also the personal consequences Hamilton faces through his relentless need to achieve and be remembered. Through the authorial choice of characterization, specially framing Hamilton against his wife, Eliza, as a foil, Miranda reveals that the pursuit of legacy often comes with real emotional costs, ones that go unnoticed until it’s too late. This shapes the musical as a whole by suggesting that legacy is not what we initially think it to be. Truthfully, legacy is not only about the things that we do but it is created through what is preserved and endured in remembrance, shaped by the people who continue to tell and protect our stories.

From Elizas introduction in Helpless, she is characterized by her vulnerability and sincerity to Hamilton, establishing her as a foil to Hamiltons ambition from the very beginning. Eliza is so open from the beginning to express her all consuming love for Hamilton shown by her repetition of saying im helpless/ im so into you/I’m down for the count

And I’m drownin’ in ’em. Her choice of language, connotes her love, and how it overwhelms her in the best way possible. In contrast, Hamilton responds to her but speaks in the terms of what he has rather than the love he can give her. He says, Eliza, I don’t have a dollar to my name, an acre of land, a troop to command, a dollop of fame immediately framing himself through status and power. The rapid rhyme in this reflects how restless and ambitious Hamiltons mind truly is and how he cannot seem to separate himself from achievement, even in a moment of love like this. In the juxtaposition of Eliza and Hamiltons characterizations, Miranda reveals that there was an initial imbalance between their relationship because for Eliza, love is enough, but for Hamilton, love must coexist with measurable things. So in this moment, the seeds of future emotional costs are already planted. The fact that Hamiltons first impression of Eliza is defined by what he has, it foreshadows the way his ambition will eventually cloud the love Eliza openly gives him.

Through characterization, Miranda further develops the relationship between Hamiton and his wife, Eliza, as foils, but now their marriage has become estranged because of their contrasting values within their relationship. From the beginning, Hamilton is characterized through his urgency, by the way he speaks and raps at a fast pace. He was constantly defining himself through his actions and chasing the next opportunity to do so. In contrast, Eliza is slow paced, willing to live in the present and value their connection not conditioned on the things they had. The contrast becomes more clear in That Would Be Enough. In the song, Eliza expresses that she doesnt need fame or power to be fulfilled, instead she wants Hamilton to slow down, find contentment in being and acknowledge the love around him. Eliza clearly knows Hamiltons inner struggles as she sings, I dont pretend to know the challenges youre facing / The worlds you keep erasing and creating in your mind, but insists for him to ,Look around, look around at how lucky we are to be alive right now Mirandas characterization of Eliza here is intentional, she is not against Hamiltons ambition, but she just hopes he recognizes that the way he chooses to love and cherish his family also creates legacy. This moment highlights the first emotional cost of Hamiltons ambition because even though he loves Eliza, he refuses to slow down or shift his priorities, pushing him away from his wife. In this characterization, Miranda wants to clearly highlight that at the expense of trying to build a future, we neglect the present and whats already around us, reinforcing the idea of how ambition cannot create remembrance alone.

Miranda deepens Elizas role as Hamiltons foil through the characterization in Burn, where the emotional cost becomes most clear. Hamilton publishes the Reynolds Pamphlet in the intention to protect his legacy but for Eliza, she experiences it as a great betrayal in the love they shared. In this, Miranda characterizes Eliza through withdrawal and grief as she says Im erasing myself from the narrative and by her burning the letters that might have redeemed you. Eliza is deeply hurt, not only because of Hamiltons infidelity but more less about the fact that Hamilton took priority in saving his reputation over honoring Elizas dignity and their relationship by publishing this document. Hamilton has spent the entire musical trying to control how history will remember him, documenting everything not realizing who he may be hurting in the process. Yet in this moment, Eliza refuses to let him control her story. Burning the letters acts as a symbol of her reclaiming her voice and her withdrawal from the story he has constructed. This scene really reveals the emotional cost of Hamiltons obsession with legacy and the way he wants to be remembered because in his need to clear his name, it leads him to subject his wife and family to public scrutiny. By this characterization, Miranda is suggesting that in the face of legacy and trying to protect it, it doesnt erase the wrongdoings within it but only shifts the burden of it onto others, who have to suffer for it. Remembrance isnt only about the goods but it’s about the bads too.

After Hamiltons death, Elizas characterization shifts. She is not just the foil to Hamiltons ambition but now the one responsible for his remembrance. In her final sequence in Who lives, who dies, who tells Your Story, she speaks about how she dedicates her life to holding Hamiltons legacy by her works of interviewing soldiers, establishing an orphanage, and telling his story. She sings And when my time is up,have I done enough?/Will they tell my story? Even after everything, Eliza still questions whether she has done enough in the light of Hamilton, who is characterized as someone who will never be satisfied. Eliza has always lived in her marriage trying to be enough for Hamilton so after death she still measures herself in what she can do to please him despite his endless expectations. Miranda makes it so that Eliza is portrayed through her devotion of continuing to tell his story so that audiences fully recognize that every trace of steps contributes to the story others must carry one day, and that loved ones ultimately inherit both the burden and power of shaping how a legacy is told, and that is what remembrance is.