Comparative Policy

This is your final paper of the Comparative Analysis assignments.

Comparative Policy Analysis paper overview

Traditional Research

Paper10-12 pages

APA formatting is required. In addition to the content, the paper must also include

1. Title Page
2. Abstract
3. Reference Page(s)

Please follow the rubric to ensure that you are addressing all aspects of the assignment.

APA formatting is crucial. You will need an APA title page, abstract, and reference page for the final assignment.

The rubric provides an outline and structure of your paper

AI is not permitted to be used for this assignment.

Rubric

SOCW 3363 Comparative Analysis Paper

CriteriaRatingsPtsThis criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome

Overview of the Social Problem / Issue

The Problem or need is defined

Extent of the problem is documented with data including the impact of the issue and the populations who are most affected

A claim is made for the the need of a policy change including how the issue and policy approaches have changed over time, and the limitations of the current policy.

5 to >4.0 pts

Excellent

The overview of the social problem/issue is discussed in depth. All aspects of the rubric are addressed including the effectiveness of the current policy.

4 to >2.0 pts

Satisfactory

The overview of the social problem/issue is discussed . Most aspects of the rubric are addressed.

2 to >0 pts

Needs Improvement

The overview of the social problem/issue may or may not be discussed. Aspects of the rubric are missing.

5 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome

Causal Theories

Discuss at least 2 causal theories that help explain the problem or the issue.

3 to >2.0 pts

Excellent

Two causal theories are discussed in depth.

2 to >0 pts

Needs Improvement

One or zero causal theories are discussed. Or there is a lack of evidence to support any of the theories.

3 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome

Current Policy Review

The US Policy is identified and reviewed

The Global Policy is identified and reviewed

The two policy are compared and/or contrasted, including policy design, funding, population served

Explain how each policy addresses (or fails to address) the underlying cause of the problem.

6 to >4.0 pts

Excellent

Both the US and Global Policy are identified and reviewed, including an overview of the major elements and financing, and the impact and outcomes of the current policy in addressing the underlying cause of the issue. The two policies are comared and contrasted.

4 to >2.0 pts

Satisfactory

The US and Global Policy are identified and briefly discussed. The comparison of the policies fail to include major aspects of the policy, including population impacted, financing or impact.

2 to >0 pts

Needs Improvement

Either the US or Global Policy is not identified or they are barely discussed. There is a lack of comparison between the two policies.

6 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome

Preferred Solution

A preferred policy solution is presented. The preferred solution is justified and/or defended through research and data. Explain how the proposed solution addresses the underlying cause of the problem.

6 to >4.0 pts

Excellent

Preferred solution is presented and justified using research and data. The paper shows how the proposed solution addresses the underlying cause of the problem.

4 to >2.0 pts

Satisfactory

Preferred solution is presented, some justification is included. Preferred solution somewhat addresses the underlying cause of the problem.

2 to >0 pts

Needs Improvement

A proposed solution is missing, or is proposed without justification or research to substantiate the solution.

6 pts

This criterion is linked to a Learning Outcome

APA Formatting / References

5 to >3.0 pts

Excellent

APA formatting is correct throughout the paper including a title page, abstract, & reference page. 20+ references are used. Research is infused throughout the paper.

3 to >1.0 pts

Satisfactory

Few APA errors. Paper includes title page, abstract and reference page. Less than 10-19 references are used. Research is concentrated in one or two sections.

1 to >0 pts

Needs Improvement

Paper is missing APA formatting. One or more of the title page, abstract, or reference page are missing. Less than 10 references are used,

5 pts

Total Points: 25